Est. 2020 · Health pages checked by a vet

Pigeons and doves explained, from wild species to fancy breeds.

Problems · 10 min read

Best Pigeon Deterrents: What Works and What Doesn’t

By Dan Richardson · First published · Last updated

Buy a physical barrier, not a gadget. Netting can close a roost or a whole opening. Spikes, coiled wire or a sloped cover will stop pigeons landing on a ledge if they cover every perch and stay clear of nest material. Owl decoys, ultrasonic boxes and most sprays are easy to find and a poor bet.

As an Amazon Associate, Pigeonpedia earns from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page may earn us a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

Which pigeon deterrents last

A separate guide to keeping pigeons away walks through food, gaps and proofing in order. This page compares the fittings and devices sold as pigeon deterrents, and the evidence behind them.

Pigeon deterrents at a glanceA comparison of common pigeon deterrents, from physical barriers that last to scare devices that fade or fail.Pigeon deterrents at a glanceTaut nettingCloses a whole space if the edges stay tightLastsSpikes and coilsBirds use gaps, or nest behind or over the arrayLasts if completeSloped or narrow ledgesAngle and width have been measured in testsLastsTensioned wiresLess obvious than spikes; may be less effectiveMixedRepellent gelNeeds regular replacement; can stain masonryShort-livedDecoys and shiny objectsBirds get used to them, often in daysFadesUltrasound and scentNo effect in a University of Basel test of 11 systemsNo effectPigeonpedia summary of Haag-Wackernagel (2000, 2008), Historic England and theRSPCA.

Some links on this page go to Amazon. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

TypeBest forMain limitUpkeep
Netting
Check price on Amazon (opens in new tab)
A void, balcony opening or loading bayLoose or gappy nets trap birdsInspect often; keep it taut
Spikes
Check price on Amazon (opens in new tab)
Sills, rails, signs and narrow ledgesBare strips and the space behind the arrayClear twigs and debris
Sloped coversWindow sills and parapetsThe angle depends on how rough the surface isLittle, if it is fixed well
Wires and coilsLedges where spikes would look too heavyMay be weaker than a full spike arrayCheck the tension
GelA short run of sillShort life; can mark porous stoneReplace it
Electric trackA ledge other systems have failed onPain-based systems did no better in testsUsually a contractor job
How the main pigeon deterrent types compare, and what upkeep they need.

Bird netting

Netting is the deterrent that can take a whole roost or opening out of use. Historic England calls it very effective when it is installed with care, and barely visible if the mesh and fixings are chosen to match the building. The same advice is clear on the risk: birds must not be able to get behind the net and become trapped.

UK government wildlife-management advice gives a mesh guide of no more than 50 mm, measured on a square mesh, for pigeons. The edges have to sit tight to the building. In a 2008 University of Basel study, free-living feral pigeons could not pass a slot 4 cm wide, a gap 5 cm high, or a square opening of 6 × 6 cm, so a gap at the edge of a net is a way in.

The RSPB says the person who puts netting up is responsible for it. If the net is there to stop birds nesting, it should be checked at least once a day, and three times a day if that can be done, so that a trapped bird can be freed and a sag or tear can be repaired. The RSPB does not recommend flimsy netting, and points to geotextile mesh or solid metal mesh as safer choices than wide-mesh nylon. The RSPCA makes the same warning: poorly fixed netting can trap pigeons and kill them.

Black mesh pigeon netting stretched under green arched ironwork and hanging lights in a station roof
Pigeon netting stretched under the roof at South Kensington station, London. Photo: CGP Grey (opens in new tab), CC BY 2.0 (opens in new tab), Wikimedia Commons.

Best for an opening or void

Bird-X Standard Bird Netting, 3/4-inch mesh, 100 × 14 ft

  • 3/4-inch (19 mm) mesh, tighter than the 50 mm UK guide for pigeons
  • UV-stabilized black mesh in a 100 × 14 ft roll
  • Listed for use on buildings and openings as well as gardens

Our take: A taut net can close a roost or opening, but only if the edges stay tight to the building. This is a large roll, so you cut it to the space. Check it often for sag or tears.

Check price on Amazon (opens in new tab)

Spikes, wires and coils

Plastic or stainless-steel spike arrays stop pigeons perching on a ledge by leaving them nowhere flat to stand. Historic England finds them effective, and also records the usual failures: they are easy to see, and they can create a new nest site in the space behind the array. The RSPCA treats blunt, well-fitted spikes as one of the more humane ways to keep pigeons off a perch, because they make landing uncomfortable and should not impale the bird.

Coverage is the whole job. In the photograph below, the spikes sit in short clumps with bare roof between them. A pigeon can step into those gaps. The same thing happens on a window sill if the last few centimetres are left clear, or if twigs and nest material are allowed to build a platform over the pins. Daniel Haag-Wackernagel’s 2000 tests in Basel found that motivated feral pigeons could get past every deterrent system he tried, spikes included, once they wanted the site enough.

Short clusters of metal bird spikes fixed in rows across a blue flat roof, with gaps of bare roof between the clusters
Bird spikes on a flat roof, with bare strips between the clusters. Photo: Tomasz Sienicki (opens in new tab), CC BY-SA 3.0 (opens in new tab), Wikimedia Commons.
A row of short upward metal spikes along the top edge of a dark sign with large pale letters
A short run of spikes along the top of a sign in Athens. Photo: Badseed (opens in new tab), CC BY-SA 4.0 (opens in new tab), Wikimedia Commons.

Best for a ledge or sill

Bird-X Stainless Steel Bird Spikes, 10 ft

  • Stainless steel pins on a polycarbonate base
  • 10 linear feet, in one-foot strips
  • Can be fixed with adhesive, screws, nails or ties, including on a curved surface

Our take: Spikes work when they cover the whole perch and stay clear of nest material. Leave a bare strip and birds will use it. Wear gloves when you fit them: the pins are sharp.

Check price on Amazon (opens in new tab)

Where spikes would be too obvious, Historic England describes spring-tensioned stainless-steel wires on posts about 1,500 mm apart, and wire coils that need fewer fixings. The wires are less obtrusive. They may also be less effective. Coils can still suit an exposed ledge or parapet. Fixings should go into mortar joints rather than into carved stone, and on a metal gutter a cable tie may be enough. On a listed building you may need permission before you drill.

Keep a pigeon emergency card on your fridge

Keep a pigeon emergency card on your fridge

A printable card with the first-hour steps for an injured or grounded pigeon, the signs that mean get help now, and who to call. Comes with a wallet-size version.

One welcome email, then one a month with new articles.

Sloped covers and narrow ledges

Some “pigeon slides” are just a smooth sheet bent to an angle, or a narrow cap that leaves the bird no ledge. The useful numbers come from a 2008 experiment by Haag-Wackernagel and Ila Geigenfeind with free-living feral pigeons in a loft in Basel. A ledge 4 cm wide was too narrow for a pigeon to sit on. The angle that stopped perching depended on the surface:

Pigeon-safe slope anglesThe minimum ledge angle that stopped free-living feral pigeons perching on smooth, medium and rough surfaces in a 2008 Basel experiment.Pigeon-safe slope angles25°Smooth:tinplate, glass,plastics35°Medium: wood,plain concrete50°Rough:sandstone, roughconcreteHaag-Wackernagel and Geigenfeind (2008), European Journal of Wildlife Research.

If you buy or make a cover, match the angle to the material, and run it the full length of the sill. A short slope with a flat patch at one end is a perch.

Gel, electric tracks and scare devices

Tacky pigeon gels are sold for sills and parapets. Historic England says they have a short life and need regular replacement, and that the gel and any sealant under it can stain or damage porous masonry. For that reason it does not recommend gel on most historic buildings. The gels are sold as a way to put a bird off landing without injuring it; they are not a permanent proofing job.

Electric tracks, which work like a livestock fence, are also on the market. In the 2000 Basel tests, systems that were meant to hurt the birds gave no better protection than harmless ones. Haag-Wackernagel argued that painful systems should be dropped.

Owl decoys, scarecrows, hanging CDs and similar visual tricks wear off. A 2012 review by Giunchi and colleagues, drawing on Johnston and Janiga’s work on feral pigeons, reports that chemical or sound devices, and visual ones such as decoys, hold only for a short time, as the birds habituate within a few days. Historic England says a model bird of prey has to be moved often if it is to have any use. Ultrasonic boxes and scent devices had no deterring effect in the Basel tests, under the conditions used there.

Traps, shooting and poison

These are not everyday pigeon deterrents, and they are a poor first choice on a house or balcony. In England, all wild birds, including feral pigeons, are protected by the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981. It is an offence, except under licence, to kill, injure or take a wild bird, to damage or destroy a nest that is in use or being built, or to take or destroy an egg. Poison is not a legal method.

For public health or public safety, an authorised person in England may rely on general licence GL41, which for 2026 covers feral pigeons for slips and falls, the spread of disease to people, and safety problems with nesting. The licence is issued for a year at a time and has conditions that must be followed. Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and other countries have their own rules. Our page on whether it is legal to shoot pigeons sets out the shooting side. Killing also has a weak record as population control. Giunchi and colleagues describe culling as one of the least reliable methods, because losses are often made up by birds moving in or by extra breeding.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most effective pigeon deterrent?

A physical barrier that the birds cannot sit on or walk through. Taut netting can close a whole roost or opening. Spikes, coils or a sloped cover can hold a ledge, if they cover every perch and stay clear of nest material. Scare devices and ultrasound are a weak choice beside those.

Do pigeon spikes work?

Yes, on a ledge they fully cover, if the pins stay too awkward to stand on. They fail when a strip is left bare, when birds nest behind the array, or when twigs are built up over the spikes. Motivated pigeons have got past spike systems in tests.

Do ultrasonic pigeon deterrents work?

Not in the test that has been published on this. Haag-Wackernagel (2000) tried an ultrasonic system on free-living feral pigeons and recorded no deterring effect, and a scent device failed in the same study.

Is pigeon gel safe for birds and buildings?

Historic England describes the gels as products designed not to harm birds, but they have a short life and can stain or damage porous masonry, so they are not recommended for most historic buildings. They need regular replacement and are not a substitute for netting or a full spike array.

Can I put up deterrents if pigeons are already nesting?

Not over an active nest, unless a licence applies. In England the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 makes it an offence to damage or destroy a nest in use or being built, except under licence. Check for eggs or young first, wait until they have fledged if you need to, then fit the deterrent so the site cannot be used again.

Sources

The claims on this page come from the sources below. Other pages on the site have more on separate guide to keeping pigeons away, on how to keep pigeons off a balcony, and on cleaning pigeon droppings.

Keep a pigeon emergency card on your fridge

Keep a pigeon emergency card on your fridge

A printable card with the first-hour steps for an injured or grounded pigeon, the signs that mean get help now, and who to call. Comes with a wallet-size version.

One welcome email, then one a month with new articles.

Last updated 20 November 2026 · Problems